Rdvk Issues Log Austin/SD5 Page 1 of 1 Submitted by Andrew Josey, The Open Group. September 11, 2007 Updated April 13 2004 Updated July 16 2004 Updated August 13 2004 Updated November 5 2004 Updated Jan 13 2005 (removed XBD ERN 8 aio_suspend, XSH ERN 29 strfmon) Updated May 5 2006 Update May 18 2006 Update June 9 2006 Update October 3 2006 Update October 24 2006 Update September 11 2007 Update March 25 2008 This document contains a log of issues that have arisen from the aardvark reports that are logged for consideration in a future revision. For those issues that are unresolved the complete aardvark is included in this document. As those issues are resolved the aardvark references are recorded below. See Austin 280r1 for part 1 of a proposed set of changes arising from this document for the next revision. See Austin 302 for part 2 of a proposed set of changes arising from this document for the next revision. See Austin 322 for part 3 of a proposed set of changes arising form this document. See Austin 325 for part 4 of a proposed set of changes arising form this document. For other changes see the 2004 aardvark reports Part 1: ------- The aardvark that have been processed via SD5 leading to proposed changes are: SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 113 (19 Jun 2003) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 4 (4 Nov 2003) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 30 (23 Dec 2003) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 39 (10 May 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 2 (18 Sep 2003) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 9 (26 Sep 2003) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 22 (6 Nov 2003) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 23 (Nov 28 2003) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 25 (12 Dec 2003) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 29 (1 Jan 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 36 (12 Apr 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 38 (12 Apr 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 43 (25 Jun 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 44 (25 Jun 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 51 (9 Aug 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 54 (29 Aug 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 56 (30 Aug 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 59 (23 Sep 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 61 (7 Oct 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 66 (9 Nov 2004) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 67 (20 Jan 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 69 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 70 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 71 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 72 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 75 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 76 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 77 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 78 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 81 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 82 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 83 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 85 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 93 (4 may 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 97 (19 may 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 100 (7 jun 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 105 (7 Aug 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 110 (27 Oct 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 111 (20 Oct 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 116 (1 dec 2005) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 120 (14 Jan 2006) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 121 (8 Jan 2006) SD5 XSHbug2 ERN 122 (19 Jan 2006) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 2 (29 Aug 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 3 (29 Aug 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 4 (24 Sep 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 5 (24 Sep 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 6 (24 Sep 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 7 (22 Sep 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 8 (30 Sep 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 9 (30 Sep 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 10 (23 Oct 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 11 (31 Oct 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 13 (7 Nov 2003) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 17 (18 Feb 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 26 (8 Jul 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 27 (24 Jun 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 30 (29 Jun 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 31 (30 Jun 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 32 (26 Jul 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 33 (26 Jul 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 37 (6 Sep 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 38 (27 Sep 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 42 (6 Oct 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 44 (5 Oct 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 45 (1 Oct 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 46 (19 Oct 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 48 (12 Nov 2004) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 50 (16 Jan 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 51 (28 Jan 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 56 (10 Mar 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 58 (28 Feb 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 60 (15 Mar 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 65 (20 Jun 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 67 (16 Jun 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 68 (21 Jun 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 69 (6 Jul 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 73 (15 Jul 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 79 (13 Dec 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 80 (13 Dec 2005) SD5 XCUbug2 ERN 81 (14 Dec 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 5 (8 Mar 2004) headers: sys/mman.h SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 6 (9 Mar 2004) headers: sys/select.h SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 10 (29 Apr 2004) headers: sys/select.h SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 13 (14 May 2004) sched.h SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 14 (3 June 2004) netdb.h SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 15 (10 Aug 2004) string.h SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 17 (28 Aug 2004) 2.1.6 options SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 21 (28 Sep 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 22 (29 Sep 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 25 (2 Nov 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 28 (4 Nov 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 30 (4 Nov 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 33 (9 Nov 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 35 (29 Nov 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 36 (10 Dec 2004) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 38 (7 Jan 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 39 (27 Jan 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 41 (7 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 42 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 43 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 44 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 48 (22 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 49 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 50 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 51 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 52 (24 Feb 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 55 (12 Mar 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 56 (14 Apr 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 57 (17 Jun 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 58 (11 Jul 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 60 (25 Aug 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 61 (4 Nov 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 62 (4 Dec 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 62 (4 Dec 2005) SD5 XBDbug2 ERN 66 (20 Feb 2006) Part 2: ------- The aardvark that have been processed via SD5 leading to proposed changes SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 120 (14 Jan 2006) SD5 XBDbug2.txt ERN 69 (11 May 2006) SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 130 (22 Feb 2006) Part 3: ------- SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 84 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 87 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 89 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 90 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 93 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 94 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 95 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 96 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 97 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 98 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 99 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 100 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 101 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 102 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 103 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 110 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 111 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 114 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 115 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 117 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 118 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 120 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 121 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 68 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 135 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 154 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 156 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 157 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 158 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 159 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 160 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 161 SD5 XRAT2bug.txt ERN 1 SD5 XRAT2bug.txt ERN 2 SD5 XRAT2bug.txt ERN 6 SD5 XRAT2bug.txt ERN 7 Part 4: ======= SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 112 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 122 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 123 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 124 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 126 SD5 XCUbug2.txt ERN 128 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 164 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 165 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 168 SD5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 169 Part 5: ========== D5 Changes for D3R (XSH) ======================== http://www.opengroup.org/austin/aardvark/latest/xshbug2.txt For each aardvark Add to CH SD5-XSH-ERN-nnn is applied. XSHbug2.txt ERN 132 XSHbug2.txt ERN 166 XSHbug2.txt ERN 170 XSHbug2.txt ERN 171 XSHbug2.txt ERN 172 XSHbug2.txt ERN 174 XSHbug2.txt ERN 175 XSHbug2.txt ERN 176 XSHbug2.txt ERN 177 XSHbug2.txt ERN 178 XSHbug2.txt ERN 179 XSHbug2.txt ERN 180 XSHbug2.txt ERN 181 XSHbug2.txt ERN 182 XSHbug2.txt ERN 183 XSHbug2.txt ERN 184 XSHbug2.txt ERN 185 XSHbug2.txt ERN 186 XSHbug2.txt ERN 187 XSHbug2.txt ERN 188 XSHbug2.txt ERN 189 XSHbug2.txt ERN 190 XSHbug2.txt ERN 191 XSHbug2.txt ERN 95 XSHbug2.txt ERN 167 XSHbug2.txt ERN 200 XSHbug2.txt ERN 201 XSHbug2.txt ERN 202 XSHbug2.txt ERN 207 XSHbug2.txt ERN 209 XSHbug2.txt ERN 148 XSHbug2.txt ERN 149 XSHbug2.txt ERN 150 XSHbug2.txt ERN 152 SD5 Changes for D3R (XCU) ======================== http://www.opengroup.org/austin/aardvark/latest/xcubug2.txt For each aardvark Add to CH SD5-XCU-ERN-nnn is applied. XCUbug2.txt ERN 129 XCUbug2.txt ERN 130 XCUbug2.txt ERN 131 XCUbug2.txt ERN 132 XCUbug2.txt ERN 133 XCUbug2.txt ERN 137 SD5 Changes for D3R (XBD) ======================== http://www.opengroup.org/austin/aardvark/latest/xbdbug2.txt For each aardvark Add to CH SD5-XBD-ERN-nnn is applied. XBDbug2.txt ERN 67 XBDbug2.txt ERN 74 XBDbug2.txt ERN 75 XBDbug2.txt ERN 76 XBDbug2.txt ERN 77 XBDbug2.txt ERN 79 XBDbug2.txt ERN 80 XBDbug2.txt ERN 81 XBDbug2.txt ERN 85 ============================================== Changes arising from SD/5 for D4R --------------------------------- Interpretations to be implemented for D4R =========================================== (not including those raised in d3r and earlier rdvk) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #092 (Approved 30/10/07 (additional changes only) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #016 (Approved 17/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #123 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #124 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #125 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #126 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #127 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #128 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #129 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #130 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #131 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #132 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #133 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #134 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #135 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #136 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #137 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #138 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #139 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #140 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #141 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #142 (Approved 17/09/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #143 (Approved 08/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #144 (Approved 08/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #145 (Approved 08/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #146 (Approved 08/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #147 (Approved 08/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #148 (Approved 08/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #149 (Approved 09/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #150 (Approved 09/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #151 (Approved 09/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #152 (Approved 09/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #153 (Approved 09/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #154 (Approved 09/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #155 (Approved 09/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #156 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #157 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #158 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #159 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #160 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #161 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #162 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #163 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #164 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #165 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #166 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #167 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #168 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #169 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #170 (Approved 11/10/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #171 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #172 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #173 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #174 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #175 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #176 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #177 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #178 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #179 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #180 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #181 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #182 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #183 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #184 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #185 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #186 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #187 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #188 (Approved 20/11/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #189 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #190 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #191 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #192 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #193 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #194 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #195 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #196 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #197 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #198 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #199 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #200 (Approved 14/12/07) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #201 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #202 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #203 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #204 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #205 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #206 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #207 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #208 (Approved 07/01/08) (N/C) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #209 (Approved 07/01/08) Austin Group Interpretation 1003.1-2001 #210 (Approved 07/01/08) SD5 Changes for D4R (XSH) ======================== XSHbug2 ERN 145 XSHbug2 ERN 193 XSHbug2 ERN 219 XSHbug2 ERN 220 XSHbug2 ERN 227 SD5 Changes for D4R (XCU) ======================== XCUbug2 ERN 149 XCUbug2 ERN 164 XCUbug2 ERN 135 XCUbug2 ERN 139 XCUbug2 ERN 141 XCUbug2 ERN 148 XCUbug2 ERN 149 XCUbug2 ERN 164 XCUbug2 ERN 171 XCUbug2 ERN 174 SD5 Changes for D4R (XRAT) ======================== XRATbug2 ERN 8 SD5 Changes for D4R (XBD) ======================== XBDbug2 ERN 53 * XBDbug2 ERN 87 XBDbug2 ERN 99 XBDbug2 ERN 105 Other changes for D4R ---------------------- Action Arising from Issue 15: See Austin/388 ISO C TC3 changes TC3 #36: XBD P228 L7852 change "values such that bitwise ORs of all combinations of the macros result in distinct values" to "values that are bitwise-distinct" (Note that this is not a direct translation of the C99 TC3 change, because we already use the term "bitwise-distinct" elsewhere for the requirement that TC3 #36 spells out verbosely.) TC3 #40: XBD P332 L11539 change "a decimal, octal, or hexadecimal constant" to "an unsuffixed integer constant" =================================================== SD5 changes for D5 XSHbug2.txt ERN 233 XSHbug2.txt ERN 235 XRATbug2.txt ERN 9 =================================================== The following aardvark remain unprocessed _____________________________________________________________________________ COMMENT Enhancement Request Number 25 jonhitchcock@hotmail.com zcat (rdvk# 6) {jjh105} Thu, 8 Jul 2004 12:38:39 +0100 (BST) _____________________________________________________________________________ Accept_____ Accept as marked below_____ Duplicate_____ Reject_X___ Rationale for rejected or partial changes: We are unaware of a normative reference or a way to develop a specification for the format _____________________________________________________________________________ Page: 0 Line: 10297 Section: compress, Problem: Edition of Specification (Year): 2004 Defect code : 1. Error The portable use of compress, uncompress and zcat appears to be limited because the standard allows for systems that do not support adaptive Lempel-Ziv coding. The last of the LZW patents listed at www.unisys.com/about__unisys/lzw exipred yesterday, so there is little reason for compression not to be implemented on systems that support the XSI option. Also, the specification says that the interchange of compressed files between implementations is not required. But to my knowledge, in practice the compressed files are portable. Action: Simplify the standard at the next revision by requiring systems that support the XSI option to implement compression using the commonly-used format. This would obviously need a difinition of the format.