Proposed resolutions are in the comment header block.
Updated 8 January 2004


 _____________________________________________________________________________
 COMMENT                                          Enhancement Request Number 1
 ktill                     Bug in COE_Linux_Platform_v1_CSQ (rdvk#  1)
 {SGI-2}                                        Fri, 2 Jan 2004 10:29:52 -0800
 _____________________________________________________________________________
 Accept_____    Accept as marked below_X___     Duplicate_____     Reject_____
 Rationale for rejected or partial changes:

Add footnote reference:
                                                                                
Defense Information Infrastructure (DII) Common Operating
Environment (COE) Integration and Runtime Specification
(I&RTS), Version 4.1, 03 October 2000 (CM-38541)  (URL
http://dod-ead.mont.disa.mil/login/login.jsp).

 _____________________________________________________________________________
 Page: 4  Line: 71  Section:


 Problem:

 need reference or guideline to determine vendor-assessed compliance
 level(1-8).  It has a reference to COE Linux Platform V1 Product
 Standard, but I cannot find appropriate information there.

 Action:

 add correct reference.

 _____________________________________________________________________________
 OBJECTION                                        Enhancement Request Number 2
 bmark@us.ibm.com              Bug in COE_Linux_Platform_v1_CSQ 1.6 (rdvk#  2)
 {IBM-007-03}                                    Fri, 19 Dec 2003 21:57:55 GMT
 _____________________________________________________________________________
 Accept_____    Accept as marked below_X___     Duplicate_____     Reject_____
 Rationale for rejected or partial changes:

Accept the change proposed below in the Action and also make an associated
change to the COE_Linux_GOV_PS document (note to ed: cross document
change) as follows:

Change lines 50-51 From: "All such changes shall be documented in the
Conformance Statement. This documentation shall include reference to
an approved Problem Report."  To: "All such changes shall require an
approved Problem Report."


 _____________________________________________________________________________
 Page: 10  Line: 205  Section: 1.6


 Problem:

 This question will always be "yes" for every platform excepting the
 "default" Linux distribution that was used by the Gov't contractors when
 developing the code. They assumed the use of tools, directory locations,
 etc. that are unique to that distributor's product. This puts every
 other applicant at a disadvantage, making this an unequal certification
 process.

 (BTW: *ALL* of the Gov't supplied validation procedures suffer from the same complaint in one form or another.)

 Action:

 The question should be removed until the GOTS code is portable.