Attendees:

HP:

Jay Rosser  (JR)     X

Jim Hamrick (JH)   X

IBM:

Kevin Reilly (KR)   X

Peter Hochschild (PH)

Intel:

nobody

InfiniSwitch:

Jimmy Hill (JHill)    X

Network Appliance:

Mark Wittle (MW)  X

Arkady Kanevsky (AK)   X

Sun:

Steve Sistare (SS)    X

Jim Roberts (JRo)    X

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last week's minutes approved except for Jay's correction.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OUI discussion:
--Discussion based on Mark Wittle's e-mail dated :  05/05/2003  02:25:09 subject: OUI document rev. 3
(MW)  - The open group will manage the IT API's connection qualifiers.
(MW) Do we have anything to say about assigment of VIA descriminators?
consensus: No
(JH) -  The IBTA is the naming authority for most of the space.
AI: MW needs to make it clear what range the ICSC is the naming for.
(MW) Do have anything to say about space from 49K to 65K?
(SS) This range is unspecifed. Developer can use these as they want.
(JR) Those and the dynamic or privte ports.
(SS) we should not say unspecifed here.
(MW) We are claiming to a 32 bit Service ID.
(SS) Values above 65K are not exposed to Consumers. (MW) Sounds good.
(MW) 49-64k say are unspecifed/ > 64K is not exposed to the Consumer.
consensus: above 64K is not exposed to consumers.
(MW) Mark is going to bring the issue of Open Group Management of this space to the Steering committee.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Started to go over DTO, EP and EVD defects
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EP sheet/line 27/global 325:
-This flag is ignored with successful return code for transports that don't have Timewait state for EP.
-Will add text to the Advice to implementers guide to clearify behavior  transport's that don't have timeWait.
-Defect goes into the (P) proposed state until text in written.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EP sheet/line 30/ global 151:
resolution:
- give advice to Consumer about the correct steps to cleanly it_ep_free().
- change the second sentence because it isn't correct.
- we add advice to implementers if you leave event on the EVD the status should be flushed.
- the status of completions not on the EVD should be flushed.
- it's in the P state with AK owing an AI:
AI: for AK to explain how to cleanly it_ep_free().
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EP sheet/line 35/global 309
resolution:
- Jay suggestion is accepted. Get rid of the default values on it_EP_create().
- defect moves to accepted(A)..
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 2/global 19
Resolution:
- new wording threshold_disabled instead of threshold_infinity.
- Jay needs to word-smith new text for threshold_disable behavior.
- defect is in the proposed state (P) until new text is submitted.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 3/global 20
-- Jay is going to propose new text.
-- Defect will remain in the (P) proposed state.
AI: for SS
-- SS will post minutes from the F-to-F meetin this issue was discussion  to the reflector.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 4/global 21
- We are going to reject this defect.
- The man page has appropriate advice about destroying the EVD.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 5/global 44
- We are going to Reject this defect.
AI: Jay to write rejection text.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 6/global 45
- Defect is left in proposed state.
AI: Jay will confirm intent with defect submitter.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 7/ global 310
- Defect Accepted (A) with JH's text as resoltion.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 8/global 346
- The resolution is defect is accept. The text will be.
-Threshold must not be greater than the size of the EVD. Similarly to "19", the value of 0 must be described.
AI: SS will create a defect on resize of EVD.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EVD worksheet/line 9/global 348
- Defect stays in proposed (P) state.
- AI: Jay will create a table.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------