Corrigendum: U065
Date: June 2006
Document: G051: The Open Group Architecture Framework
(TOGAF - 'The Book')
I915: TOGAF Version 8.1 Enterprise Edition,
Online edition (previously located at:
www.opengroup.org/architecture/togaf8-doc/arch/)
Code: 12/07/06 U065 (I915/G051)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The page and section numbers used in this Corrigendum refer to
the printed document G051. The online references (e.g., "chap05.htm")
are to the associated online Architecture Forum review version which
was used in the formation of this Corrigendum. The "TOGAF CR nn"
references provide a record of the Architecture Forum review.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/01 (TOGAF CR 16)
Title: Inconsistent Numbering of Architecture Versions
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Throughout Phase A-D there are places where there are
misleading version numbers used to describe architecture
models. It is not that they are incorrect, but that they
use inconsistent numbering formats.
Change: Add the following text to Page 20, Section 3.2.2, Basic
Structure, final paragraph (Online ref: chap03.htm) and
to Page 117, Section 16.1, Introduction, replacing the
final sentence ("The initial version ...")
(Online ref: chap16.htm):
"In all cases, the ADM numbering scheme is provided
as an example. It should be adapted by the architect
to meet the requirements of the organization and to
work with the architecture tools and repositories employed
by the organization."
Make the following changes to the Inputs and Outputs:
o Page 41, Section 5.5, Outputs, change the list
(as amended by U065/14) after "..., including:"
to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
o Page 49, Section 6.3, Inputs, change the list
(as amended by U065/18) after "..., including:"
to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
o Page 52, Section 6.5, Outputs, change the third
bullet to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
including:
Change the fourth bullet to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
if appropriate
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
o Page 55, Section 7.3, Inputs, change the seventh
and eighth bullets to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
if appropriate
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed)
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
(Online ref: chap07.htm)
o Page 55, Section 7.5, Outputs, change the second
and third bullets to the following:
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
(Online ref: chap07.htm)
o Page 57, Section 8.3, Inputs, change the seventh
and eighth bullets to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
if appropriate
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed)
Change the 2 new bullets added by U065/31 to the
following:
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 0.1, if available
o Target Data Architecture, Version 0.1, if available
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
o Page 61, Section 8.5, Outputs, change the second
bullet to the following:
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 1.0
[This change supersedes TOGAF CR 58.]
Change the fourth bullet to the following:
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
o Page 65, Section 9.3, Inputs, change the seventh
and eighth bullets to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
if appropriate
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed)
Change the tenth and eleventh bullets to the following:
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 0.1,
if appropriate and if available
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 0.1, if
available
[This change supersedes TOGAF CR 62.]
(Online ref: chap09.htm)
o Page 70, Section 9.5, Outputs, change the second
bullet to the following:
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
[This change supersedes TOGAF CR 66.]
Change the fourth bullet to the following:
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
(Online ref: chap09.htm)
o Page 72, Section 10.3, Inputs, insert 2 new
bullets after the fourth bullet as follows:
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
(from Phase A)
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
(from Phase A)
[This change supersedes TOGAF CR 70.]
Change the eighth through eleventh bullets to
the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
if appropriate
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 1.0, if appropriate
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 1.0,
if appropriate
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed)
Change the thirteenth and fourteenth bullets to
the following:
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
o Page 74, Section 10.5, Outputs, change the second
bullet to the following:
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 1.0,
if appropriate
[This change supersedes TOGAF CR 76.]
Change the fifth bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 1.0
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 77, Section 10.6.3.3, Inputs, change the eighth
through eleventh bullets to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
if appropriate
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 1.0, if appropriate
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 1.0,
if appropriate
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed)
Change the thirteenth and fourteenth bullets to
the following:
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
Insert 2 new bullets after the fourth bullet
as follows:
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 78, Section 10.6.3.5, Outputs, change the second
bullet to the following:
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.2:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 80, Section 10.6.4.3, Inputs, change the third
and fourth bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.2
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 81, Section 10.6.4.5, Outputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.3:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 82, Section 10.6.5.3, Inputs, change the first
and second bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.3:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 83, Section 10.6.5.5, Outputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.4:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 85, Section 10.6.6.3, Inputs, change the first
and second bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.4
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 85, Section 10.6.6.5, Outputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.5:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 86, Section 10.6.7.3, Inputs, change the first
and second bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (business goals)
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.5
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 86, Section 10.6.7.5, Outputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.6:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 88, Section 10.6.8.3, Inputs, change the first
and second bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.6
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 88, Section 10.6.8.5, Outputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.7:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 90, Section 10.6.9.3, Inputs, change the first
and second bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.7
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 91, Section 10.6.9.5, Outputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.8:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 93, Section 10.6.10.3, Inputs, change all
bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.8
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 95, Section 10.6.10.5, Outputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 1.0:
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
o Page 98, Section 11.3, Inputs, change the third
through sixth bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
(Online ref: chap11.htm)
o Page 102, Section 12.3, Inputs, change the third
and fourth bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0
(Online ref: chap12.htm)
The following changes are also needed to the Zachman
Framework mapping (Chapter 39) to reflect the changes
above. Note that the outputs that have been added in
TOGAF 8.1.1 may need to be added here with appropriate
mapping in a future version.
o Page 462, Section 39.3.2, Phase A, after fourth
bullet, change the sublist items to:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Page 463, Section 39.3.3, Phase B, change the
third and fourth bullets to the following:
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed)
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1.0 (detailed),
if appropriate
o Page 464, Section 39.3.4, Phase C (Data), change the
second and fourth bullets to the following:
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 1.0, if appropriate
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1.0:
o Page 466, Section 39.3.5, Phase C (Appls), change the
second and fourth bullets to the following:
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 1.0,
if appropriate
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1.0:
o Page 468, Section 39.3.6, Phase D (Step 1), change the
second bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.2:
o Page 469, Section 39.3.6, Phase D (Step 2), change the
first bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.3:
o Page 470, Section 39.3.6, Phase D (Step 3), change the
first bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.4:
o Page 471, Section 39.3.6, Phase D (Step 4), change the
first bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.5:
o Page 471, Section 39.3.6, Phase D (Step 8), change the
first bullet to the following:
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 1.0:
(Online ref: chap39.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/02 (TOGAF CR 02)
Title: Architecture Framework
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: We have agreed that the "A" in TOGAF stands
for "Architecture" not "Architectural".
Change: Throughout the text wherever there is a reference to
an "Architectural Framework", change it to "Architecture
Framework".
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/03 (TOGAF CR 42)
Title: Information Systems Architectures
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: There could be more than one system.
Change: Throughout the text, change to "Information Systems
Architectures".
This change should also be made to the following graphics:
o Page 19, Figure 3.1 (adm.gif)
o Page 20, Figure 3.2 (adm_exp.gif)
o Page 31, Figure 4.1 (prelim.gif)
o Page 35, Figure 5.1 (a_vis.gif)
o Page 42, Figure 6.1 (b_bus.gif)
o Page 53, Figure 7.1 (c_inf.gif)
o Page 71, Figure 10.1 (d_tech.gif)
o Page 96, Figure 11.1 (e_opp.gif)
o Page 99, Figure 12.1 (f_mig.gif)
o Page 103, Figure 13.1 (g_gov.gif)
o Page 106, Figure 14.1 (h_cha.gif)
o Page 111, Figure 15.1 (req_mgt.gif)
o Page 342, Figure 32.1 (adm-bbs.gif)
o Page 375, Figure 34.5 (adm.gif)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/04 (TOGAF CR 06)
Title: Definition of Technology Architecture
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: The definition of Technology Architecture is much
narrower than the views described in Phase D.
Change: On Page 6, under "What kind of architecture does
TOGAF deal with?", change the last bullet to:
"A Technology Architecture - this describes the
logical software and hardware capabilities that are
required to support the deployment of business,
data, and application services. This includes IT
infrastructure, middleware, networks, communications,
processing, standards, etc.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/05 (TOGAF CR 10, 11, 12, 13)
Title: Business Principles and Pre-existing Inputs
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: According to Part IV, Architecture Principles,
Business Principles are a subset of Architecture Principles.
These inputs will be pre-existing from either the
Preliminary Phase or a previous iteration of the ADM.
Change: On Page 38, Section 5.3, Inputs, change the second and
third bullets to the following:
o Business strategy, business goals, and business drivers
o Architecture principles (see Architecture Principles),
including business principles, when pre-existing
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/06 (TOGAF CR 14)
Title: Business Principles
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: According to Part IV, Architecture Principles,
Business Principles are a subset of Architecture Principles.
Change: On Page 38, Section 5.4, Steps, change the 2nd step
to the following:
2. Business Goals and Business Drivers
Identify the business goals and strategic drivers of the
organization.
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
See also U065/08.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/07 (TOGAF CR 15)
Title: Business Principles
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: According to Part IV, Architecture Principles,
Business Principles are a subset of Architecture Principles.
Change: On Page 38, Section 5.4, Steps, change the 3rd step
to the following:
3. Architecture Principles, including Business Principles
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
See also U065/08.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/08 (TOGAF CR 73)
Title: Process Steps
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Instead of just listing the steps, state in proper
sentence form what needs to be done.
Change: Use complete sentences to describe process steps.
Detailed changes are as follows:
Page 38, Section 5.4, Steps, change major steps as follows:
1. Establish the Project
2. Identify Business Goals and Business Drivers
3. Review Architecture Principles, including Business Principles
4. Define Scope
5. Define Constraints
6. Identify Stakeholders and Concerns, Business Requirements, and
Architecture Vision
7. Develop Statement of Architecture Work and Secure Approval
Page 49, Section 6.4, Steps, change major steps as follows:
1. Develop Baseline Business Architecture Description
2. Identify Reference Models, Viewpoints, and Tools
3. Create Architecture Model(s)
4. Select Business Architecture Building Blocks (e.g., business services)
5. Conduct Formal Checkpoint Review of Architecture Model and Building
Blocks with Stakeholders
6. Review Non-Functional (Qualitative) Criteria (e.g., performance, costs,
volumes) (and move following sentence to new paragraph)
7. Complete Business Architecture
8. Perform Gap Analysis (see Approach) and Create Report
On Page 58, Section 8.4, Steps, change major steps as follows:
1. Develop Baseline Data Architecture Description
2. Review and Validate Principles, Reference Models, Viewpoints, and Tools
3. Create Architecture Model(s)
4. Select Data Architecture Building Blocks
5. Conduct Formal Checkpoint Review of Architecture Model and
Building Blocks with Stakeholders
6. Review Qualitative Criteria (e.g., performance, reliability,
security, integrity)
(and move following sentence to new paragraph)
7. Complete Data Architecture
8. Conduct Checkpoint/Impact Analysis
(and move following sentence to new paragraph)
9. Perform Gap Analysis (see Approach) and Create Report
On Page 65, Section 9.4, Steps, change major steps as follows:
1. Develop Baseline Applications Architecture
2. Review and Validate Principles, Reference Models, Viewpoints, and Tools
3. Create Architecture Model(s)
4. Identify Candidate Application Systems
5. Conduct Formal Checkpoint Review of Architecture Model and Building
Blocks with Stakeholders
6. Review Qualitative Criteria (e.g., security, availability, performance,
costs)
(and move following sentence to new paragraph)
7. Complete Applications Architecture
8. Perform Gap Analysis (see Approach) and Create Report
On Page 73, Section 10.4, Steps, change major steps as follows:
1. Develop Baseline Technology Architecture Description
2. Develop Target Technology Architecture; see detailed steps
(and move following sentence to new paragraph)
On Page 98, Section 11.4, Steps, change the steps as follows:
1. Identify Key Business Drivers Constraining Sequence of Implementation
(and move examples to new paragraph)
2. Review Gap Analysis from Phase D
3. Brainstorm Technical Requirements from Functional Perspective
4. Brainstorm Co-existence and Interoperability Requirements
5. Perform Architecture Assessment and Gap Analysis
6. Identify Major Work Packages or Projects
(and move following sentence to new paragraph)
On Page 104, Section 13.4, Steps, change major steps as follows:
1. Formulate Project Recommendation
(and move following sentence to new paragraph)
2. Document Architecture Contract
3. Review Ongoing Implementation Governance and Architecture Compliance
On Page 110, Section 14.4, Steps, change steps as follows:
1. Monitor Technology Changes
2. Monitor Business Changes
3. Assess Changes and Development of Position to Act
4. Arrange Meeting of Architecture Board (or other governing council)
(and move following sentence to new paragraph)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/09 (TOGAF CR 17)
Title: Architecture Vision Description
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: The Architecture Vision should include all architecture
domains and its development is not dependent on the
use of the business scenarios technique alone.
Change: On Page 39, Section 5.4, Steps, change the 2nd bullet
under the 6th step to the following:
"This step will generate the first, very
high-level definitions of the baseline and target
environments, from a business, information systems,
and technology perspective, including:"
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/10 (TOGAF CR 18, 19)
Title: Architecture Vision Description
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: The Architecture Vision should include all architecture
domains.
Change: On Page 39, Section 5.4, Steps, change the sublist
after the 6th step, 2nd bullet to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Business Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Data Architecture, Version 0.1
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 0.1
[The version numbers here are as determined by U065/01.]
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/11 (TOGAF CR 20)
Title: Business Principles
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: According to Part IV, Architecture Principles,
Business Principles are a subset of Architecture Principles.
Change: On Page 41, Section 5.5, Outputs, change the first bullet
on this page to the following:
o Refined statements of business goals and strategic drivers
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/12 (TOGAF CR 21)
Title: Business Principles
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: According to Part IV, Architecture Principles,
Business Principles are a subset of Architecture Principles.
Change: On Page 41, Section 5.5, Outputs, change the second bullet
on this page to the following:
o Architecture principles (see Architecture Principles),
including business principles
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/13 (TOGAF CR 22, 23)
Title: Architecture Vision Description
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Architecture Vision and Business Scenario outputs
appear to be the same thing. Output should be called
Architecture Vision.
Change: On Page 41, Section 5.5, Outputs, merge the third and
fourth bullets on this page as follows:
o Architecture Vision (Business Scenario/Architecture
Vision), including:
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/14 (TOGAF CR 24, 25)
Title: Architecture Vision Description
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: The Architecture Vision should include all architecture
domains.
Change: On Page 41, Section 5.5, Outputs, change the list
after "..., including:" to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 1
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 1
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 1
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 1
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1
[The version numbers here are superseded by U065/01.]
(Online ref: chap05.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/15 (TOGAF CR 27)
Title: TeleManagement Forum
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Is the TeleManagement Forum a relevant reference?
Change: On Page 46, Section 6.2.4, Enterprise Continuum, change
the link to www.tmforum.org.
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/16 (TOGAF CR 28)
Title: Business Principles
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: According to Part IV, Architecture Principles,
Business Principles are a subset of Architecture Principles.
These inputs will be pre-existing from either the
Preliminary Phase or a previous iteration of the ADM.
Change: On Page 48, Section 6.3, Inputs, change the third and
fourth bullets to the following:
o Refined statements of business goals and strategic drivers
o Architecture principles (see Architecture Principles),
including business principles, when pre-existing
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/17 (TOGAF CR 29)
Title: Architecture Vision Description
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Architecture Vision and Business Scenario outputs
appear to be the same thing. Output should be called
Architecture Vision.
Change: On Page 49, Section 6.3, Inputs, delete "/Business
Scenario" from the first bullet on this page.
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/18 (TOGAF CR 30, 31)
Title: Architecture Vision Description
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: The Architecture Vision should include all architecture
domains.
Change: On Page 49, Section 6.3, Inputs, change the list
after "..., including:" to the following:
o Baseline Business Architecture, Version 1
o Baseline Technology Architecture, Version 1
o Baseline Data Architecture, Version 1
o Baseline Applications Architecture, Version 1
o Target Business Architecture, Version 1
o Target Technology Architecture, Version 1
o Target Data Architecture, Version 1
o Target Applications Architecture, Version 1
[The version numbers here are superseded by U065/01.]
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/19 (TOGAF CR 34)
Title: Business Architecture Models
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Business data should be described at this point.
Change: On Page 50, Section 6.4, Steps, under the 3rd step,
list item (ii), insert a new list item (g):
"Business data model".
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/20 (TOGAF CR 37)
Title: Business Architecture Report
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: The distinction between report and document is unclear.
Change: On Page 51, Section 6.4, Steps, change list item (vii) to
the following: "Prepare the Business Architecture Report,
comprising some or all of:".
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/21 (TOGAF CR 36)
Title: Business Architecture Report
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: The distinction between report and document is unclear.
Change: On Page 51, Section 6.4, Steps, under the 7th step,
change list item (vi) to the following: "Document
rationale for building block decisions in the Business
Architecture description document". (The
report is developed in the next step.)
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/22 (TOGAF CR 38)
Title: Business Goals
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Goals and objectives are required at enterprise level.
Change: On Page 52, Section 6.5, Outputs, change the third bullet,
second sublist item to: "Business goals and objectives,
for the enterprise and each organizational unit".
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/23 (TOGAF CR 39)
Title: Business Services
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Services may not necessarily be confined to one business
unit.
Change: On Page 52, Section 6.5, Outputs, change the third bullet,
fourth sublist item to: "Business services - the services
that the enterprise and each enterprise unit provides to its
customers, both internally and externally".
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/24 (TOGAF CR 40)
Title: Business Data Model
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Business data and information should be described in the
Business Architecture.
Change: On Page 52, Section 6.5, Outputs, under the third bullet,
add a new penultimate sublist item: "Business data model".
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/25 (TOGAF CR 41)
Title: Technical Requirements
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Technical requirements includes Information Systems
Architectures.
Change: On Page 52, Section 6.5, Outputs, seventh bullet, delete
"(drivers for the Technical Architecture work)".
(Online ref: chap06.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/26 (TOGAF CR 43)
Title: Consistency
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Terminology should be consistent between phases.
Change: On Page 55, Section 7.3, Inputs, change the seventh bullet
on this page to: "Gap analysis results (from Business
Architecture)".
(Online ref: chap07.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/27 (TOGAF CR 44)
Title: Data Architectures
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Data Architecture includes Baseline.
Change: On Page 55, Section 7.5, Outputs, change the second
bullet to:
o Baseline Data Architecture
o Target Data Architecture
[The version numbers are added by U065/01.]
(Online ref: chap07.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/28 (TOGAF CR 45)
Title: Applications Architecture
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Applications Architecture includes Baseline.
Change: On Page 55, Section 7.5, Outputs, change the third
bullet to:
o Baseline Applications Architecture
o Target Applications Architecture
[The version numbers are added by U065/01.]
(Online ref: chap07.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/29 (TOGAF CR 46)
Title: Gap Analysis
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Consistency.
Change: On Page 55, Section 7.5, Outputs, change the eighth
bullet to: "Gap analysis results:".
(Online ref: chap07.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/30 (TOGAF CR 47)
Title: Gap Analysis
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Consistency.
Change: On Page 57, Section 8.3, Inputs, change the sixth
bullet to: "Gap analysis results (from Business
Architecture)".
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/31 (TOGAF CF 48)
Title: Consistency
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Data Architecture is an input to the Applications
Architecture.
Change: On Page 58, Section 8.3, Inputs, insert new penultimate
bullets:
o Baseline Data Architecture, if available
o Target Data Architecture, if available
[The version numbers are added by U065/01.]
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/32 (TOGAF CR 49)
Title: Terminology
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Consistency.
Change: On Page 58, Section 8.4, Steps, change the 1st step to:
"Baseline Data Architecture Description".
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
See also U065/08.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/33 (TOGAF CF 50)
Title: Data Architecture
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Clarify meaning of "Conceptual Data Model".
Change: On Page 58, Section 8.4, Steps, change the first bullet
under the 1st step to: "Business data model ...".
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/34 (TOGAF CR 51)
Title: Data Architecture
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: "of interest" - to whom? Improve clarity.
Change: On Page 58, Section 8.4, Steps, change the second bullet
under the 1st step to: "Logical data model (logical views
of the actual data of interest from the applications
point of view)".
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/35 (TOGAF CR 53)
Title: Data Architecture
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Improve clarity.
Change: On Page 59, Section 8.4, Steps, change list item (a)
under the 3rd step, list item (ii) to: "Business data
model ...".
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/36 (TOGAF CR 54)
Title: Terminology
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Consistency.
Change: On Page 59, Section 8.4, Steps, change the final bullet
under list item (ii) to:
o Time permitting, relate entities to the application
systems described in the Baseline Applications
Architecture Description
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/37 (TOGAF CR 56)
Title: Terminology
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Metamodels are not building blocks. Metamodels are
architecture components/assets which assist in
developing building blocks; they are not building
blocks themselves.
Change: On Page 60, Section 8.4, Steps, change the 4th step
to the following: "Select Data Architecture Building
Blocks" (i.e., delete reference to metamodels).
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/38 (TOGAF CR 57)
Title: Qualitative Criteria
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Throughout TOGAF we use inconsistent terms for
non-functional attributes/functions; aka qualitative
criteria.
Change: On Page 60, Section 8.4, Steps, change the 6th step
to the following:
Review Qualitative Criteria (e.g., performance, reliability,
security, integrity)
Review the qualitative criteria, providing as many
measurable criteria as possible (e.g., costs, minimum
tolerable data losses, maximum data volumes at peak
times, etc.). ...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/39 (TOGAF CR 59)
Title: Terminology
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: Improve clarity.
Change: On Page 60, Section 8.4, Steps, 7th step, change the first
bullet under list item (vii) to: "Business data model".
On Page 61, Section 8.5, Outputs, change the first sublist
item under the fourth bullet to: "Business data model".
(Online ref: chap08.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/40 (TOGAF CR 61)
Title: Gap Analysis
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Consistency.
Change: On Page 65, Section 9.3, Inputs, change the sixth bullet
to the following:
o Gap analysis results (from Business Architecture)
(Online ref: chap09.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/41 (TOGAF CR 64)
Title: Is this a good time to be brainstorming?
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: We mention brainstorming here and elsewhere in the ADM.
Brainstorming would be most appropriate in Phase A.
Change: On Page 68, Section 9.4, Steps, change the 4th step,
list item (v) to: "Consider other potential ...".
(Online ref: chap09.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/42 (TOGAF CR 69)
Title: Change of Name
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: If the architecture referred to is "technology" then
the principles should be technology principles.
Change: On Page 72, Section 10.3, Inputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Technology principles (Technology Principles), if existing
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/43 (TOGAF CR 72)
Title: Terminology
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Consistency.
Change: On Page 73, Section 10.4, Steps, change the 1st step
to: "Baseline Technology Architecture Description".
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
See also U065/08.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/44 (TOGAF CR 75)
Title: Reviews with Stakeholders
Qualifier: Major Technical
Rationale: Make consistent recommendations about reviews with
stakeholders in each phase. It seems we have slightly
different recommendations about when and how to review
our progress and gather feedback from the stakeholders
and/or sponsors. There should be a consistent approach
for these activities across Phases B, C, & D.
Change: On Page 73, Section 10.4, Steps, delete step 1(v).
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/45 (TOGAF CR 32, 33, 63, 67, 68, 74, 77, 79, 80)
Title: Improve Phase D Graphics
Qualifier: Major Editorial
Rationale: In response to these CRs, it was agreed that overall
improvement of the process steps will be undertaken
in TOGAF9.
Change: On Page 74-76, replace the text in Section 10.6.2
(including Figure 10.2) with the following:
"An organization creating or adapting a Technology
Architecture may already mandate the use of a list
of approved suppliers/products for that organization.
The list will be an input to the definition of the
organization-specific architecture framework. The
architectures can then be used as procurement tools
to govern the future growth and development of the
organization's IT infrastructure. The key steps are
expanded in the following subsections.
Note: The order of the following steps should be
adapted to the situation as described in Introduction
to the ADM."
On Page 89, Section 10.6.9.1, delete the 3rd sentence:
"Technology Architecture Development shows this as
two boxes, captioned as Steps 7a and 7b, but in reality
the process is more complicated."
Remove the Phase D process steps diagrams as follows:
o Step 1 (Page 76)
o Step 2 (Page 79)
o Step 3 (Page 81)
o Step 4 (Page 84)
o Step 5 (Page 86)
o Step 6 (Page 87)
o Step 7 (Page 89)
o Step 8 (Page 92)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/46 (TOGAF CR 81)
Title: Change of Name
Qualifier: Minor Technical
Rationale: These should be Technology Principles because they are
about Technology Architecture; the data and application
principles are equally "technical" in nature.
Change: On Page 77, Section 10.6.3.3, Inputs, change the first
bullet to the following:
o Technology principles (Technology Principles), if existing
(Online ref: chap10.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/47 (TOGAF CR 102)
Title: Incorrect Reference
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: The book numbering is out of sequence.
Change: On Page 162, Section 10.11, Security Services should be
Section 20.11.
(Online ref: chap20.htm)
(Applies to Guide only.)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/48 (TOGAF CR 84)
Title: Link
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: The link is password protected and thus adds no value
to the text.
Change: On Page 439, Section 37.2.1, Overview, delete footnote
number 22 (3rd line).
(Online ref: chap37.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/49 (TOGAF CR 106)
Title: Typo in Graphic
Qualifier: Major Editorial
Rationale: There is a typo in the graphic.
Change: On Page 391, Figure 35.2, CISITAF Technical Reference
Model (CISITAF_image004.gif): change "Sowtware" to
"Software".
(Online ref: chap35.htm)
Further changes to the graphics have been identified
by The Open Group Editor as follows:
On Page 75, Figure 10.2 (ta_detail.gif):
o Highest box, change to: "Baseline from Phases B & C"
o Leftmost box, change to: "Constraints from Phases B & C"
On Page 94, Table 10.1 (table41.gif):
o Top-left cell, change "Current Architecture" to
"Baseline Architecture"
o Eliminated Services/Shared Screen Services,
change to "Unintentionally excluded - a gap in
Target Architecture"
On Page 183, Figure 22.2 (p3_iii2.gif):
o Top Down View, middle of box, should be
"Operating System Services"
On Page 184, Figure 22.3 (p3_iii1.gif):
o Top Down View, middle of box, should be "Operating
System Services"
o Side View, center "Network Services"
On Page 186, Figure 22.5 (p3_iii4.gif):
o Topmost text on left of picture, break line after
"Languages"
o Topmost text on right of picture, right align
"Meta Indices"
On Page 206, Figure 24.1 (comp_levels.gif):
o Add missing ")" to text for "Irrelevant"
o Add full-stops to text for "Irrelevant", "Consistent",
"Fully Conformant", and "Non-Conformant" (also note hyphen)
On Page 210, Figure 24.2 (revuproc.gif):
o Fix left-alignment under all boxes, especially re bullets
On Page 235, Figure 26.1 (concepts.gif):
o Change to "Organizational" (in two places)
On Page 238, Figure 26.2 (org.gif):
o Change to "Program Management Office" (top center)
On Page 279, top figure (skills1.gif):
o Add full-stops to text for "Background" and "Awareness"
o In the text for "Awareness", change to "... background,
issues, and implications ..."
On Page 279, bottom figure (skills3.gif):
o Under "IT Architect Roles", change to "Organization"
o Under "IT Architect Roles", last row should be
"Business Functions"
On Page 280, top figure (skills4.gif):
o Under "IT Architect Roles", change to "Organization
Design" and "Systems Behavior"
On Page 280, bottom figure (skills5.gif):
o Under "IT Architect Roles", change to "Program or
Project Management", "Program Management", and
"Change Management"
On Page 281, top figure (skills6.gif):
o Under "IT Architect Roles", change to "Web-Based Services"
On Page 294, Figure 31.1 (table1_taxonomy_arch_views.gif):
o Change top-right box to: "Acquirers, Operators,
Administrators, & Managers (note "Acq" and additional comma)
On Page 295, Figure 31.2 (table2_mapping_taxonomy.gif):
o Network/Enterprise Model, top box, change to
"... (Business-to-Location Mapping)"
o Function/System Model, middle box, change to
"Application-to-Application Communication View"
On Page 321, Figure 31.11 (figa-6.gif):
o Top right box, change to: "Data Mgmt ..."
On Page 326, Figure 31.14 (figa-9.gif):
o Text for Layer 7, add full-stop
o Text for Layer 6, add comma after "e.g." and add full-stop
o Text for Layer 5, add full-stop to end of first line,
and change to "Establishes dialogue ..."
o Text for Layer 3, start new line before "Manages flow ...
o Text for Layer 1, start new line before "Defines
electrical ...", and add comma after "mechanical"
On Page 342, Figure 32.1 (adm-bbs.gif):
o Top left box, 1st bullet: "High-level ..."
o Bottom left box, 1st bullet: "Building block ..."
and delete full-stop
o Right-hand box, text for Step 1, change to: "Identify
relevant Architecture Building Blocks ..." and
delete full-stop
o Right-hand box, text for Step 3, change to:
"High-level ..." and delete full-stop
o Right-hand box, text for Step 4, change to: "library
of ABBs, re-using ..." and delete full-stop
(from both bullets)
o Right-hand box, text for Step 5, delete full-stop
o Right-hand box, text for Step 7, change 1st bullet to:
"... each ABB, re-using ..." and delete full-stop;
delete full-stop from 2nd and 3rd bullets; change
4th bullet to: "... that might be re-used, ..."
and delete full-stop; correct typo in 5th bullet
("rationale") and delete full-stop
o Right-hand box, text for Step 8, delete full-stops
from 1st and 4th bullets
[On Page 354, Figure 32:6, this figure is misplaced.
Move to Page 353, before Section 32.4.6, Architectural
Model level (Phases B, C, and D).]
On Page 354, Figure 32.7 (figj-6.gif):
o Change bullets under "Architecture Principles"
(top right) to:
o The existing architecture model is founded on the
mainframe.
o Databases are tied to application logic.
o Security is embedded in the application.
(Note these do need full-stops because they are each
full sentences.)
On Page 355, Figure 32.8 (figj-7.gif):
o Rightmost text is missing - resize graphic or rearrange text
On Page 364, Figure 32.12 (figj-11.gif) and 32.13 (figj-12.gif):
o Change 2nd top box to "SOAP1 application" (i.e.,
remove space as SOAP2)
On Page 390, Figure 35.1 (CISITAF_image002.gif):
o Bottom line of text, change to ".../subsystem"
(i.e., remove hyphen)
On Page 391, Figure 35.2 (CISITAF_image004.gif):
o Middle box, far right, change to "Internationalization"
On Page 409, Figure 35.11 (ukmodtrm.gif):
o Two different abbreviations are used for "Management";
change 2nd one (under Data Management Services) to
"Database Mgmt"
On Page 413, Figure 35.12 (nato-001.gif):
o In the "Stakeholder" circle, add comma after "priorities"
o In the central text, change to "High-level Target
Architecture & Implementation Plan" and "Baseline
Description"
o In right-hand blue circle, change to "Architects
& Planners ..."
o Under right-hand blue circle, change to "Transitional
Architecture(s)"
o In yellow circle, add comma after "users"
On Page 414, Figure 35.13 (nato-002.gif):
o Top right box, typo "Remanent" should be "Permanent"
o Top right 2nd box (yellow), "... site-specific ..."
o Top right 3rd box (green)), "... site-specific ..."
o Text lower right, change all 3 to "... -independent"
On Page 415, Figure 35.14 (nato-003.gif):
o Top left blue box, "organization"
On Page 415, Figure 35.15 (nato-004.gif):
o Bottom box, change to: "Use of off-the-shelf ..."
On Page 420, Figure 35.16 (afp.gif):
o Yellow circle, "Architecture Framework Process"
o Top white box, "Organization"
On Page 444, Figure 37.2 (pgde-cycle.gif):
o Change "Life Cycle" to "Lifecycle" (in 2 places)
On Page 446, Figure 37.5 (feaf-matrix.gif):
o Middle column, change to "Applications
Architecture" (in 2 places)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/50 (TOGAF CR 07, 08, 09)
Title: Incorrect Illustration
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: The Preliminary Phase is not shown. We should ensure
the whole graphic is used correctly and consistently
throughout. It is acceptable to identify parts of the
graphic being discussed in sections to ensure graphic
is not misleading.
Change: Fix ADM graphics to include the Preliminary Phase, as
per Page 31, Figure 4.1:
o Page 35, Figure 5.1 (a_vis.gif)
o Page 42, Figure 6.1 (b_bus.gif)
o Page 53, Figure 7.1 (c_inf.gif)
o Page 71, Figure 10.1 (d_tech.gif)
o Page 96, Figure 11.1 (e_opp.gif)
o Page 99, Figure 12.1 (f_mig.gif)
o Page 103, Figure 13.1 (g_gov.gif)
o Page 106, Figure 14.1 (h_cha.gif)
o Page 111, Figure 15.1 (req_mgt.gif)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/51 (TOGAF CR 85)
Title: Dead link?
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Link is not useful.
Change: On Page 447, Section 37.9.1, Overview, delete footnote
number 23 (3rd line).
(Online ref: chap37.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Change Number: U065/52 (TOGAF CR 86)
Title: Dead link?
Qualifier: Minor Editorial
Rationale: Link is not useful.
Change: On Page 450, Section 37.12.1, Overview, delete footnote
number 24 (2nd line).
(Online ref: chap37.htm)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
END OF U065